0347 The Reliability of the Most Recent Tooth Color Measuring Devices
A. ŠOZIć, A. ELZOHAIRY, G. KHASHAYAR, and A.J. FEILZER, University of Dentistry, Amsterdam, Netherlands

The electronic instruments for tooth color measurement available on the market have a different measuring geometry and different internal and external configuration. However, the color reproduction process with available dental porcelain requires them to provide uniform color information to the dental laboratory. This color information corresponds mainly with the codes of Vita classical shade tabs. Objectives: This study evaluated the reliability of the five most recent instruments for color measurement in dentistry, and the resemblance in the color values between them in correspondence to Vita. Methods: Two operators (OPI and OPII) assessed the color of the middle third of shades A1, A2, A3, A3.5 and A4 five times with ShadeEye (SE), ShadeScan (SS), Identa Color II (IC), Ikam (IK) and Easy Shade (ES) instrument. Intra-operator reliability from five measurements of five different colors per instrument was assessed by Cohen's Kappa, and the resemblance between the instruments in obtained color values was expressed in % of the scores that corresponded with the codes of the measured Vita shade guide tabs. Results:

SE

%

IC

%

SS

%

IK

%

ES

%

OP I

0.785

77.5

0.537

5

1

90

0.901

100

1

100

OPII

0.805

82.5

0.901

12.5

0.899

85

0.646

87.5

1

100

Conclusions: ES, IK and SS showed the highest correspondence with Vita shade guide and SS the lowest. There seems to be more variation in Kappa's between the operators than between the instruments, probably due to the sensitivity of the handling procedure.

Seq #34 - Diagnostic Systems
4:00 PM-6:00 PM, Friday, 27 August 2004 Crowne Plaza Hotel AVSA II

Back to the Scientific Program Program
Back to the Joint Meeting of the Continental European, Israeli, and Scandinavian (NOF) Divisions of the IADR (August 25 -- 28, 2004)

Top Level Search