| 1475 Evaluation of Accuracy of A Newly Developed Dental Multi-Spectrophotometer | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
S. NAGAI1, D. NATHANSON2, H. WEBER1, Y. KOMIYA3, T. WADA3, N. SATO3, T. TERUI4, and K. ISHIBASHI5, 1Harvard University, School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA, USA, 2Boston University, USA, 3Olympus, Tokyo, Japan, 4Iwate Medical University, School of Dentistry, Morioka, Japan, 5Iwate Medical University, Morioka, Japan Objectives: The purpose of this study is to analyze the measuring accuracy and operators error of a newly developed prototype dental multi-spectrophotometer (Handy-MSC, Olympus) that utilizes 8-band LEDs built into the hand-held camera head. The device takes approximately 0.25sec to obtain 8-band image. Methods: Color measurements of 8 shade tabs (VITAPAN A1, A3, A4, 1M-1, 2M-1, 3M-1, 4M-1, 5M-1) were performed using 5 spectrophotometers: Shade-Scan (MHT); MSC-2000 (Olympus); CAS-ID1 (Iwate Med. Univ); PR-650 (Photo-Research); and Handy-MSC (Olympus). The color data obtained by CAS-ID1, an analyzer documented to eliminate edge-loss error and match perceptional readings accurately (Ishikawa, et al, Int J Prosthodont, 1994), was used as control. The color differences between CAS-ID1 and the other units were calculated. The color of the central incisor (upper right) was measured 5 times by 5 operators each using the Handy-MSC and dE among measurements and operators were calculated. Data were analyzed using ANOVA and Fishers PLSD tests. Results: Color differences are listed in the table:
Shade-Scan and PR-650 indicated significantly higher dL* values (p<0.01). PR-650 showed a lower da* (p<0.05) and db* (p<0.05) values. Shade-Scan had a higher db* (p<0.01) and MSC-2000 indicated a higher da* (p<0.05). Handy-MSC and MSC-2000 produced significantly lower mean dE values (p<0.01). The mean dE values among measurements were 0.36±0.23 and 0.67±0.41 among operators. Conclusion: Data obtained suggest that all units tested have no edge-loss, however readings by Shade-Scan and PR-650 may not match perceptional readings. MSC-2000 and Handy-MSC had readings that matched perceptional readings with a clinically acceptable dE. Thus, the compact Handy-MSC has demonstrated accurate and stable readings that can be useful dental-clinical application. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Seq #159 - Assessment of Color and Esthetics 12:30 PM-2:30 PM, Thursday, 11 March 2004 Hawaii Convention Center 321-B | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Back to the Prosthodontics Research Program
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||